A story in stages
Numbers did not arrive all at once. They came in stages, and each new stage answered a question the older one could not. Counting gave us the natural numbers. The need to write down "none" gave us zero. The need to write down a debt gave us negative numbers. We will follow that story all the way to the integers, and then look at the rules of sign that Brahmagupta wrote down in 628 CE. We still use them today, unchanged.
Counting: the natural numbers
The oldest mathematical act is matching. Picture a herder who cannot count. He can still drop one pebble in a pot for each animal that goes out, and take one out for each animal that comes back. When the pot is empty, the whole herd is home. This one-to-one correspondence is what a number is before it has a name.
Give names to the sizes of such collections, and you have the natural numbers.
The earliest records we have are tally marks cut into bone, tens of thousands of years old. Much later, in the Indian subcontinent, the place-value system was perfected, and with it you can write any natural number using just ten symbols.
Natural numbers are closed under addition. That means adding two of them always gives another natural number. They are closed under multiplication too. But they are not closed under subtraction. Try : there is no answer inside .
Zero: nothing becomes a number
Older systems left a blank, or put a placeholder mark, in an empty column. But they did not treat "nothing" as a quantity you could calculate with. The step from placeholder to real number was taken in India. The Bakhshālī manuscript uses a dot for zero. Brahmagupta, in the Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta, defined zero as what is left when a number is taken away from itself, , and he gave its arithmetic.
The word he used, śūnya, comes from śūnyatā, the philosophical idea of emptiness. It makes sense, doesn't it? A culture already at ease with emptiness as an idea was ready to accept it as a number.
Negative numbers: recording a debt
If , then what is ? Brahmagupta answered with the language of the market. A positive number is a fortune (dhana) and a negative number is a debt (ṛṇa). If you owe , we write it as .
Put the natural numbers, their negatives and zero together, and you get the integers.
On the number line, the negatives sit to the left of zero. Each one is the mirror image of its positive partner.

Brahmagupta's rules of sign
- Fortune plus fortune is fortune: .
- Debt plus debt is debt: . If you owe and borrow more, you owe .
- Fortune plus debt: take the smaller size from the larger, and keep the sign of the larger. ; .
- Debt times fortune is debt: . Think of three debts of each.
- Debt times debt is fortune: . If three debts of are removed, you are better off.
Rule 5 puzzles many students, so here is a way to think about it. Read as "take away three lots of". If someone takes away three lots of a -rupee debt from you, you have gained .
Subtracting a negative works the same way as adding a positive: . Having a -rupee debt cancelled is just as good as receiving .
Worked examples
Example 1. The temperature at noon in Leh is C. By midnight it has fallen degrees. So the midnight temperature is C. Cold!

Example 2. A trader borrows ₹, then earns ₹, then loses ₹. Where does he stand? , which is a debt of ₹.
Example 3. Compute: (i) . (ii) . (iii) . (iv) . (v) .
Example 4. A lift starts at floor , goes down floors, up , down . It ends up on floor , right where it began.

Practice
- Are the natural numbers closed under division? Give two examples to support your answer.
- A merchant receives copper pieces for every bags of grain. How many pieces for bags?
- A submarine at m rises m, then dives m. Where is it?
- Compute: (a) ; (b) ; (c) ; (d) ; (e) ; (f) .
- A student's account shows (a debt). Three payments of each are cancelled. What is the balance now, and which rule of sign did you use?
- Explain, using money, why .
- Write the integers between and in increasing order.
Answers
Show answers
- No. is a natural number, but and are not.
- groups, pieces.
- m.
- (a) . (b) . (c) . (d) . (e) . (f) .
- Cancelling three debts of : . Debt times debt is fortune.
- Having ₹ and being freed of a ₹ debt leaves you as well off as having ₹.
- .