A story in stages

Num­bers did not arrive all at once. They came in stages, and each new stage answered a ques­tion the older one could not. Count­ing gave us the nat­ural num­bers. The need to write down "none" gave us zero. The need to write down a debt gave us neg­a­tive num­bers. We will fol­low that story all the way to the inte­gers, and then look at the rules of sign that Brah­magupta wrote down in 628 CE. We still use them today, unchanged.

Count­ing: the nat­ural num­bers

The old­est math­e­mat­i­cal act is match­ing. Pic­ture a herder who can­not count. He can still drop one peb­ble in a pot for each ani­mal that goes out, and take one out for each ani­mal that comes back. When the pot is empty, the whole herd is home. This one-to-one cor­re­spon­dence is what a num­ber is before it has a name.

Give names to the sizes of such col­lec­tions, and you have the nat­ural num­bers.

N={1,2,3,4,…}\mathbb{N} = \{1, 2, 3, 4, \ldots\}

The ear­li­est records we have are tally marks cut into bone, tens of thou­sands of years old. Much later, in the Indian sub­con­ti­nent, the place-value sys­tem was per­fected, and with it you can write any nat­ural num­ber using just ten sym­bols.

Nat­ural num­bers are closed under addi­tion. That means adding two of them always gives another nat­ural num­ber. They are closed under mul­ti­pli­ca­tion too. But they are not closed under sub­trac­tion. Try 3−53 - 5: there is no answer inside N\mathbb{N}.

Zero: noth­ing becomes a num­ber

Older sys­tems left a blank, or put a place­holder mark, in an empty col­umn. But they did not treat "noth­ing" as a quan­tity you could cal­cu­late with. The step from place­holder to real num­ber was taken in India. The Bakhshālī man­u­script uses a dot for zero. Brah­magupta, in the Brāh­mas­phuṭasid­dhānta, defined zero as what is left when a num­ber is taken away from itself, a−a=0a - a = 0, and he gave its arith­metic.

a+0=a,a−0=a,a×0=0a + 0 = a, \qquad a - 0 = a, \qquad a \times 0 = 0

The word he used, śūnya, comes from śūny­atā, the philo­soph­i­cal idea of empti­ness. It makes sense, does­n't it? A cul­ture already at ease with empti­ness as an idea was ready to accept it as a num­ber.

Neg­a­tive num­bers: record­ing a debt

If 5−5=05 - 5 = 0, then what is 3−53 - 5? Brah­magupta answered with the lan­guage of the mar­ket. A pos­i­tive num­ber is a for­tune (dhana) and a neg­a­tive num­ber is a debt (ṛṇa). If you owe 22, we write it as −2-2.

Put the nat­ural num­bers, their neg­a­tives and zero together, and you get the inte­gers.

Z={…,−3,−2,−1,0,1,2,3,…}\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, 3, \ldots\}

On the num­ber line, the neg­a­tives sit to the left of zero. Each one is the mir­ror image of its pos­i­tive part­ner.

Number line from -5 to 5: zero in the middle, positives (fortunes) in green to the right, negatives (debts) in red to the left, with -3 and 3 joined as mirror images.
The inte­gers on the num­ber line.

Brah­magup­ta's rules of sign

  1. For­tune plus for­tune is for­tune: 6+3=96 + 3 = 9.
  2. Debt plus debt is debt: (−6)+(−3)=−9(-6) + (-3) = -9. If you owe 66 and bor­row 33 more, you owe 99.
  3. For­tune plus debt: take the smaller size from the larger, and keep the sign of the larger. 8+(−5)=38 + (-5) = 3; 5+(−8)=−35 + (-8) = -3.
  4. Debt times for­tune is debt: (−4)×3=−12(-4) \times 3 = -12. Think of three debts of 44 each.
  5. Debt times debt is for­tune: (−4)×(−3)=12(-4) \times (-3) = 12. If three debts of 44 are removed, you are 1212 bet­ter off.

Rule 5 puz­zles many stu­dents, so here is a way to think about it. Read (−3)×(-3) \times as "take away three lots of". If some­one takes away three lots of a 44-rupee debt from you, you have gained 1212.

Sub­tract­ing a neg­a­tive works the same way as adding a pos­i­tive: 10−(−4)=1410 - (-4) = 14. Hav­ing a 44-rupee debt can­celled is just as good as receiv­ing 44.

Worked exam­ples

Exam­ple 1. The tem­per­a­ture at noon in Leh is 6∘6^\circC. By mid­night it has fallen 1717 degrees. So the mid­night tem­per­a­ture is 6−17=−11∘6 - 17 = -11^\circC. Cold!

Number line from -12 to 8 with an arrow jumping 17 degrees to the left from the noon temperature of 6 degrees Celsius to the midnight temperature of -11 degrees Celsius.
Exam­ple 1: 6 minus 17 is minus 11.

Exam­ple 2. A trader bor­rows ₹12001200, then earns ₹18501850, then loses ₹700700. Where does he stand? −1200+1850−700=−50-1200 + 1850 - 700 = -50, which is a debt of ₹5050.

Exam­ple 3. Com­pute: (i) (−9)×6=−54(-9) \times 6 = -54. (ii) (−7)×(−8)=56(-7) \times (-8) = 56. (iii) 0−(−13)=130 - (-13) = 13. (iv) (−36)÷4=−9(-36) \div 4 = -9. (v) (−36)÷(−4)=9(-36) \div (-4) = 9.

Exam­ple 4. A lift starts at floor 33, goes down 55 floors, up 99, down 44. It ends up on floor 3−5+9−4=33 - 5 + 9 - 4 = 3, right where it began.

A vertical scale of floors from -3 to 8; the lift starts at floor 3, goes down 5 to floor -2, up 9 to floor 7, then down 4, ending at floor 3 again.
Exam­ple 4: the lift ends on floor 3.

Prac­tice

  1. Are the nat­ural num­bers closed under divi­sion? Give two exam­ples to sup­port your answer.
  2. A mer­chant receives 1212 cop­per pieces for every 33 bags of grain. How many pieces for 2727 bags?
  3. A sub­ma­rine at −45-45 m rises 2828 m, then dives 6060 m. Where is it?
  4. Com­pute: (a) (−15)+(−22)(-15) + (-22); (b) 18+(−31)18 + (-31); (c) (−11)×7(-11) \times 7; (d) (−9)×(−12)(-9) \times (-12); (e) −6−(−19)-6 - (-19); (f) (−84)÷(−7)(-84) \div (-7).
  5. A stu­den­t's account shows −250-250 (a debt). Three pay­ments of −120-120 each are can­celled. What is the bal­ance now, and which rule of sign did you use?
  6. Explain, using money, why 25−(−10)=3525 - (-10) = 35.
  7. Write the inte­gers between −4-4 and 33 in increas­ing order.

Answers

Show answers
  1. No. 6÷3=26 \div 3 = 2 is a nat­ural num­ber, but 3÷63 \div 6 and 7÷27 \div 2 are not.
  2. 27÷3=927 \div 3 = 9 groups, 9×12=1089 \times 12 = 108 pieces.
  3. −45+28−60=−77-45 + 28 - 60 = -77 m.
  4. (a) −37-37. (b) −13-13. (c) −77-77. (d) 108108. (e) 1313. (f) 1212.
  5. Can­celling three debts of 120120: −250−3(−120)=−250+360=110-250 - 3(-120) = -250 + 360 = 110. Debt times debt is for­tune.
  6. Hav­ing ₹2525 and being freed of a ₹1010 debt leaves you as well off as hav­ing ₹3535.
  7. −3,−2,−1,0,1,2-3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2.