Two gems from Indian geom­e­try

Four side lengths are not enough to fix a quadri­lat­er­al's area. But if the quadri­lat­eral is cyclic, they are. Brah­magupta found the for­mula in 628 CE. It looks a lot like Heron's for­mula, and in fact it con­tains Heron's as a spe­cial case. We will state the for­mula, test it on shapes whose areas we already know, and talk about what "spe­cial case" and "gen­er­al­i­sa­tion" mean in math­e­mat­ics. We end with Baud­hāyana's con­struc­tion of a square with the same area as a given rec­tan­gle.

Sides alone are not enough

Four rods of length 33 hinged at their ends make a rhom­bus. Open it out into a square and the area is 99. Push it over a lit­tle and the area drops to about 88. Push it flat­ter and it is about 5.45.4. The sides never change, yet the area does. So to fix the area of a quadri­lat­eral you need some­thing more: an angle, a diag­o­nal, or some prop­erty of the fig­ure.

Three rhombi with all sides 3: opened square the area is 9, pushed over a little it is about 8, and pushed flatter it is about 5.4, though the sides never change.
Same four sides, three dif­fer­ent areas.

Brah­magup­ta's for­mula

The extra prop­erty that works most beau­ti­fully is that the quadri­lat­eral is cyclic, mean­ing its ver­tices lie on a cir­cle. Then, with sides a,b,c,da, b, c, d and semi-perime­ter s=a+b+c+d2\displaystyle s = \dfrac{a + b + c + d}{2},

Area=(s−a)(s−b)(s−c)(s−d)\text{Area} = \sqrt{(s - a)(s - b)(s - c)(s - d)}

A new for­mula should always be tested on shapes we already under­stand.

Test on a rec­tan­gle, since every rec­tan­gle is cyclic. The sides are a,b,a,ba, b, a, b, so s=a+bs = a + b, and the for­mula gives b⋅a⋅b⋅a=ab\sqrt{b \cdot a \cdot b \cdot a} = ab ✓.

Test on a square of side aa. Here s=2as = 2a, and the area is a4=a2\sqrt{a^4} = a^2 ✓.

Test on an isosce­les trapez­ium, which is also always cyclic, with par­al­lel sides 2a2a and 2b2b and equal slant sides cc: s=a+b+cs = a + b + c, so

Area=(b+c−a)(a+c−b)(a+b)(a+b)=(a+b)c2−(b−a)2\text{Area} = \sqrt{(b + c - a)(a + c - b)(a + b)(a + b)} = (a + b)\sqrt{c^2 - (b - a)^2}

Now, c2−(b−a)2\sqrt{c^2 - (b - a)^2} is exactly the trapez­i­um's height. So this is (half the sum of the par­al­lel sides) ×\times height, just as it should be ✓.

Exam­ple 1. A cyclic quadri­lat­eral has sides 5,5,12,125, 5, 12, 12 in order round the cir­cle. Here s=17s = 17, so the area is =12×12×5×5=60= \sqrt{12 \times 12 \times 5 \times 5} = 60. Does that make sense? It is a kite made of two 55–1212–1313 right tri­an­gles on a com­mon hypotenuse 1313, which is a diam­e­ter, so yes, it fits.

A kite ABCD inscribed in a circle with sides 5, 12, 12 and 5; the diagonal AC of 13 is a diameter, and the angles at B and D are right angles.
Exam­ple 1: two 5, 12, 13 right tri­an­gles on a com­mon diam­e­ter.

Exam­ple 2. A cyclic quadri­lat­eral has sides 7,15,20,247, 15, 20, 24. Here s=33s = 33, and the area is =26×18×13×9=54756=234= \sqrt{26 \times 18 \times 13 \times 9} = \sqrt{54756} = 234.

Spe­cial cases and gen­er­al­i­sa­tion

A spe­cial case is what a gen­eral result becomes when you add an extra con­di­tion. Going the other way, the gen­eral result is called a gen­er­al­i­sa­tion of the spe­cial case. You have met this idea many times already.

  • The square's area a2a^2 is the rec­tan­gle's abab with b=ab = a.
  • For an isosce­les right tri­an­gle, a2+b2=c2a^2 + b^2 = c^2 with a=ba = b becomes c=a2c = a\sqrt{2}.
  • (a+b)2=a2+2ab+b2(a + b)^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2 is (a+b+c)2=a2+b2+c2+2ab+2bc+2ca(a + b + c)^2 = a^2 + b^2 + c^2 + 2ab + 2bc + 2ca with c=0c = 0.

Heron is a spe­cial case of Brah­magupta. Think of a tri­an­gle as a cyclic quadri­lat­eral whose fourth side has shrunk to zero, so that two ver­tices have merged. Put d=0d = 0. The semi-perime­ter becomes the tri­an­gle's ss, and

(s−a)(s−b)(s−c)(s−0)=s(s−a)(s−b)(s−c)\sqrt{(s - a)(s - b)(s - c)(s - 0)} = \sqrt{s(s - a)(s - b)(s - c)}

which is Heron's for­mula. So the like­ness between the two for­mu­las was no coin­ci­dence at all.

Squar­ing a rec­tan­gle

In ancient geom­e­try, to "square" a shape meant to con­struct a square with the same area. Baud­hāyana's Śul­basū­tra (c. 800 BCE) shows how to do it for a rec­tan­gle of sides a>ba > b.

  1. On the longer side, mark off bb from one end, leav­ing a piece of length a−ba - b; find its mid­point. This gives a length b+a−b2=a+b2\displaystyle b + \dfrac{a - b}{2} = \dfrac{a + b}{2} from that end.
  2. Draw a square of side a+b2\displaystyle \dfrac{a + b}{2} on it; one ver­tex HH lies on the shorter side extended, at dis­tance a+b2−b=a−b2\displaystyle \dfrac{a + b}{2} - b = \dfrac{a - b}{2} beyond the rec­tan­gle's cor­ner.
  3. With cen­tre HH and radius a+b2\displaystyle \dfrac{a + b}{2}, draw an arc to cut the rec­tan­gle's far side at KK.
  4. The per­pen­dic­u­lar from KK to the line through HH has length HPHP with, by the Baud­hāyana–Pythago­ras the­o­rem,

HP2=(a+b2)2−(a−b2)2=ab\displaystyle HP^2 = \left(\frac{a + b}{2}\right)^2 - \left(\frac{a - b}{2}\right)^2 = ab

So the square on HPHP has area abab, which is the rec­tan­gle's area. What a lovely idea: the con­struc­tion is really the iden­tity (a+b2)2−(a−b2)2=ab\displaystyle \left(\dfrac{a + b}{2}\right)^2 - \left(\dfrac{a - b}{2}\right)^2 = ab, drawn with a com­pass.

A rectangle a by b beside a right triangle with hypotenuse (a + b)/2 and one leg (a - b)/2; the other leg is root ab, and the square on it has the rectangle area ab.
The square on root ab has the same area as the rec­tan­gle.

Squar­ing a tri­an­gle fol­lows eas­ily. A tri­an­gle of base bb and height hh has the same area as a rec­tan­gle b×h2\displaystyle b \times \dfrac{h}{2}, and we already know how to square that rec­tan­gle.

Prac­tice

  1. Find the area of the cyclic quadri­lat­eral with sides 3,4,3,43, 4, 3, 4 taken in order, and say what shape it must be.
  2. Find the area of the cyclic quadri­lat­eral with sides 6,8,6,86, 8, 6, 8 taken in that order.
  3. A cyclic quadri­lat­eral has sides 8,9,12,138, 9, 12, 13. Find its area.
  4. A cyclic quadri­lat­eral has sides 25,39,52,6025, 39, 52, 60. Find its area.
  5. Ver­ify Brah­magup­ta's for­mula for a kite made of two con­gru­ent right tri­an­gles with legs 66 and 88 joined along their hypotenuses, whose sides in order round the cir­cle are 6,8,8,66, 8, 8, 6.
  6. Apply Brah­magup­ta's for­mula with d=0d = 0 to sides 5,12,135, 12, 13 and com­pare with the right-tri­an­gle area.
  7. A rec­tan­gle is 1616 cm by 44 cm. What is the side of the square with the same area, and what are the two lengths a+b2\displaystyle \dfrac{a + b}{2} and a−b2\displaystyle \dfrac{a - b}{2} that Baud­hāyana's con­struc­tion uses?
  8. Give an exam­ple of a gen­eral state­ment and one of its spe­cial cases from geom­e­try.

Answers

Show answers
  1. s=7s = 7: 4×3×4×3=12\sqrt{4 \times 3 \times 4 \times 3} = 12. Oppo­site sides equal and cyclic: a rec­tan­gle 3×43 \times 4.
  2. s=14s = 14: 8×6×8×6=48\sqrt{8 \times 6 \times 8 \times 6} = 48; a 6×86 \times 8 rec­tan­gle.
  3. s=21s = 21: 13×12×9×8=11232≈105.98\sqrt{13 \times 12 \times 9 \times 8} = \sqrt{11232} \approx 105.98.
  4. s=88s = 88: 63×49×36×28=3111696=1764\sqrt{63 \times 49 \times 36 \times 28} = \sqrt{3111696} = 1764.
  5. Sides in order 6,8,8,66, 8, 8, 6 (the equal sides adja­cent): s=14s = 14, 8×6×6×8=48\sqrt{8 \times 6 \times 6 \times 8} = 48; the two tri­an­gles have area 2424 each ✓. Note the order 6,8,6,86, 8, 6, 8 gives the same num­ber here but describes a rec­tan­gle, a dif­fer­ent fig­ure.
  6. s=15s = 15: 10×3×2×15=900=30=12×5×12\displaystyle \sqrt{10 \times 3 \times 2 \times 15} = \sqrt{900} = 30 = \dfrac{1}{2} \times 5 \times 12 ✓.
  7. Area 6464, side 88 cm. 16+42=10\displaystyle \dfrac{16 + 4}{2} = 10 and 16−42=6\displaystyle \dfrac{16 - 4}{2} = 6; indeed 102−62=6410^2 - 6^2 = 64.
  8. For exam­ple: "the angles of a tri­an­gle add to 180∘180^\circ" has the spe­cial case "each angle of an equi­lat­eral tri­an­gle is 60∘60^\circ".