From Counting Numbers to Integers: Zero and Negatives, Class 9
How counting began with one-to-one matching and tally bones, how zero became a number in Brahmagupta's work, and how debts and fortunes give the integers and their rules for adding and multiplying.
Every number you use today has a story. People first needed numbers to keep track of animals, days and goods. Much later they needed a number for "nothing", and then numbers for debts. This lesson follows that journey: from counting, to zero, to the integers, and the rules that tell us how to add and multiply them.
Counting before number words
Matching one thing with another
Picture a herder in an old farming village beside the Saraswati river. Each morning the cattle walk out to graze, and each evening they come home. The herder has no words for numbers and no written numerals. How can the herder tell whether a calf is lost?
A simple trick works. As each cow leaves, drop one pebble into a pot. As each cow returns, take one pebble out. If the pot ends up empty, every cow is home. If some pebbles are left, that many cows are missing. Pairing each cow with exactly one pebble is called one-to-one correspondence. You do not need to know the word "fourteen" to use it; you only need to match things up.
This matching idea is where the natural numbers come from:
N={1,2,3,4,…}
Worked example 1
A goatherd puts one pebble in a pot for each goat that goes out in the morning, 23 pebbles in all. In the evening one pebble is removed for each goat that returns, and 21 pebbles are removed. What does the pot tell the goatherd?
Each returning goat cancels one pebble, so the pebbles still in the pot stand for goats that have not come back.
23−21=2
Two pebbles remain, so two goats are still missing.
Numbers carved in bone
The chapter tells us that the oldest physical records of counting are tally marks cut into bone, found in Africa. The Lebombo bone, from the Lebombo Mountains between South Africa and Swaziland, is about 35,000 years old and carries 29 neat notches of equal size. Researchers think it may have been used to follow the phases of the Moon, a way of tracking time with natural numbers.
The Ishango bone, found near the source of the Nile in the Democratic Republic of Congo, dates to around 20,000 BCE. It has three columns of notches. One column holds groups of 11, 13, 17 and 19 notches. These are exactly the prime numbers between 10 and 20, the numbers whose only factors are 1 and themselves. Another column seems to show doubling. So the idea of a number is tens of thousands of years old.
Tally groups of 11, 13, 17 and 19: the four primes between 10 and 20, like the groups on one column of the Ishango bone.
Is subtraction always possible with natural numbers?
Add two natural numbers and you always get a natural number: 4+9=13. We say the natural numbers are closed under addition. Subtraction is different. 9−4=5 is fine, but 3−5 has no answer among 1,2,3,…, and neither does 5−5. So the natural numbers are not closed under subtraction. This gap is exactly what zero and the negative numbers will fill.
Large numbers in the Indian tradition
Trade needed careful counting
In cities of the Indus Valley Civilisation, such as Lothal and Harappa, weights and measures were standardised. Merchants who traded pottery, lapis lazuli or cotton with Mesopotamia needed reliable ways to count and keep accounts.
Names for powers of ten
Thinkers of the Vedic period were fascinated by very large numbers. The Vedas give names to every power of 10 up to 1012, which was called parārdha. In the Lalitavistara, Buddha names numbers up to 1053, called tallakṣhaṇa. The Ṛigveda already expressed quantities using powers of 10. This habit prepared the ground for the place-value system based on powers of 10 that grew up in India and is now used all over the world, and it helped lead to the idea of zero.
Worked example 2
How many times larger is tallakṣhaṇa than parārdha?
10121053=1053−12=1041
Tallakṣhaṇa is 1041 times parārdha: a 1 followed by 41 zeros.
Counting on finger joints
A practice still seen in India is to count with the thumb on the joints of the other four fingers of the same hand. Each finger has 3 joints, so one hand counts 4×3=12. This is one natural way a counting system built on twelves (base 12) could arise.
Zero: when nothing became a number
A placeholder is not yet a number
For a very long time the number line began at 1. If you gave away all five of your apples, you had no number for what you held. The Babylonians and the Mayans used a mark to show an empty place inside a written number, but they did not add, subtract or multiply with "nothing".
From śhūnyatā to śhūnya
In the Upanishads and in Buddhist writings, śhūnyatā (emptiness) was a state sought through yoga and meditation: a mind emptied of all vṛttis, its restless movements. The word śhūnya means zero. Patanjali's Yoga Sutras also describe how this emptiness helps control mind, body and senses. Because Indian thinkers valued emptiness, they were ready to accept "nothing" as a real idea. The idea travelled into architecture, literature and linguistics, and then into mathematics in the work of Āryabhaṭa and finally Brahmagupta.
The Bakhśhālī Manuscript, dated by the book to the early centuries CE, uses a bold dot (bindu) for zero. A symbol, however, becomes a number only when it has rules.
Brahmagupta's rules for zero
In his Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta (628 CE), Brahmagupta defined zero as what you get when a number is taken away from itself, a−a=0. He then stated how zero behaves:
Adding zero changes nothing: a+0=a.
Subtracting zero changes nothing: a−0=a.
Multiplying by zero gives zero: a×0=0.
For example, 48+0=48, 48−0=48 and 48×0=0. With these rules, zero is a number you can calculate with, not just an empty place.
Integers: numbers to the left of zero
Fortunes and debts
If 5−5=0, what is 3−5? Brahmagupta answered with ideas from trade. He spoke of two kinds of quantity:
Dhana (fortune): positive numbers, like money you own.
Ṛiṇa (debt): negative numbers, like money you owe.
So 3−5=−2: if you have ₹3 and must pay ₹5, you end up owing ₹2. The negative numbers sit to the left of zero on the number line. Putting together the positive whole numbers, their negatives and zero gives the integers:
Z={…,−3,−2,−1,0,1,2,3,…}
The letter Z comes from the German word Zahlen, meaning "numbers". The integers are closed under subtraction: the difference of any two integers is again an integer.
Brahmagupta's rules for integers
Brahmagupta's rules are the ones we still use:
Fortune plus fortune is fortune: 5+4=9.
Debt plus debt is debt: (−5)+(−4)=−9. Owe ₹5, borrow ₹4 more, and you owe ₹9.
Fortune minus zero is fortune; debt minus zero is debt: 7−0=7 and −6−0=−6.
Debt times fortune is debt: (−3)×4=−12. Four debts of ₹3 each make a debt of ₹12.
Debt times debt is fortune: (−3)×(−4)=12.
Adding two debts on the number line: start at 0, move 5 left, then 4 more left, landing on −9.
Worked example 3
(a) Find (−7)+(−6). (b) A shopkeeper has ₹9 in the drawer and must pay a bill of ₹14. What is her position?
(a) Two debts add to a bigger debt: (−7)+(−6)=−13.
(b) The fortune is +9 and the bill is a debt of 14:
9+(−14)=−(14−9)=−5
She is ₹5 in debt. When a fortune and a debt are combined, take the difference of their sizes and give it the sign of the one with the larger size.
Why is a debt times a debt a fortune?
The book asks us to think of multiplying by a negative number as removing. Suppose you have four debts of ₹3 each. If someone takes away those four debts, you are ₹12 better off than before. Taking away (the "−") four debts of −3 gives +12:
(−3)×(−4)=+12
A pattern gives the same answer. Look at multiples of −2 as the second number goes down by 1 each time:
(−2)×3(−2)×2(−2)×1(−2)×0(−2)×(−1)=−6=−4=−2=0=?
Each answer is 2 more than the one above it. To keep the pattern going, (−2)×(−1) must be 0+2=2, and (−2)×(−2) must be 4. Any other choice would break the rules we already trust.
Worked example 4
Work out (a) (−6)×(−5), (b) (−8)×3, (c) 0×(−9), (d) 15−(−4).
(a) Debt times debt is fortune: (−6)×(−5)=30.
(b) Debt times fortune is debt: (−8)×3=−24.
(c) Anything times zero is zero: 0×(−9)=0.
(d) Subtracting a debt means a debt is taken away from you. If you have ₹15 and someone cancels a ₹4 debt you owed, you are ₹4 richer. So subtracting −4 is the same as adding 4:
15−(−4)=15+4=19
Worked example 5
At dawn the temperature in Dras is −3∘C. By night it has fallen by 12∘C. The next afternoon it is 20∘C higher than that night reading. Find both temperatures.
Night: −3−12Afternoon: −15+20=−15∘C=5∘C
A fall is a move to the left on the number line; a rise is a move to the right.
Division of integers
Division undoes multiplication, so its sign rules match. Since (−3)×4=−12, we get (−12)÷4=−3 and (−12)÷(−3)=4. Like signs give a positive quotient; unlike signs give a negative one.
Common mistakes
Writing (−5)+(−4)=9 or −1. Two debts always make a larger debt: the answer is −9.
Thinking (−3)×(−4)=−12 "because both are negative". The product of two negatives is positive.
Reading 10−(−5) as 10−5. Subtracting a negative adds: 10−(−5)=15.
Believing zero is a natural number. In this chapter N starts at 1; zero joins with the integers.
Saying a×0=a. Adding zero leaves a number unchanged, but multiplying by zero gives zero.
Assuming natural numbers are closed under subtraction. 3−5 is not a natural number.
Try these
Find (−9)+(−8). Answer:−17
Find (−4)×(−11). Answer:44
Find 6−(−9). Answer:15
A potter borrows ₹700, then earns ₹950, then loses ₹300. Find the final position. Answer:−700+950−300=−50, a debt of ₹50
A herder drops a pebble for each of 14 cows going out and removes one for each of 11 returning. How many pebbles remain, and what do they mean? Answer: 3 pebbles; 3 cows are missing
Which primes lie between 20 and 30? Answer: 23 and 29
Key terms
One-to-one correspondence
Pairing each object of one group with exactly one object of another group, as with cows and pebbles.
Natural numbers
The counting numbers 1,2,3,…, written N.
Prime number
A natural number greater than 1 whose only factors are 1 and itself, such as 11, 13, 17 and 19.
Closure
A set is closed under an operation if doing that operation on any two of its members always gives a member of the same set.
Śhūnya
The Sanskrit word for zero; śhūnyatā means emptiness.
Dhana and ṛiṇa
Brahmagupta's names for fortunes (positive numbers) and debts (negative numbers).
Integers
The whole numbers together with their negatives and zero, written Z.
Parārdha
The Vedic name for 1012.
Common questions
Is zero positive or negative?
Neither. Zero is the dividing point of the number line: positive integers lie to its right and negative integers to its left.
Who first treated zero as a number?
According to the chapter, Brahmagupta, in the Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta (628 CE), defined zero as a−a and gave rules for adding, subtracting and multiplying with it.
Why is subtracting a negative the same as adding?
Subtracting a debt means a debt is cancelled, which leaves you richer by that amount. So 10−(−5)=10+5=15.
Why is the set of integers called Z?
The letter comes from the German word Zahlen, which means numbers.
What was special about the Ishango bone?
One column of its notches is grouped as 11, 13, 17 and 19, the primes between 10 and 20, and another column seems to show doubling.
References
National Council of Educational Research and Training. Ganita Manjari: Textbook of Mathematics, Grade 9 (Part I). NCERT, New Delhi.
Burton, D. M. Elementary Number Theory. McGraw-Hill Education.