Expresswala Academy Mathematics Tuition

The World of Numbers (Class 9)

From Counting Numbers to Integers: Zero and Negatives, Class 9

How counting began with one-to-one matching and tally bones, how zero became a number in Brahmagupta's work, and how debts and fortunes give the integers and their rules for adding and multiplying.

By 11 min read

Every num­ber you use today has a story. Peo­ple first needed num­bers to keep track of ani­mals, days and goods. Much later they needed a num­ber for "noth­ing", and then num­bers for debts. This les­son fol­lows that jour­ney: from count­ing, to zero, to the inte­gers, and the rules that tell us how to add and mul­ti­ply them.

Count­ing before num­ber words

Match­ing one thing with another

Pic­ture a herder in an old farm­ing vil­lage beside the Saraswati river. Each morn­ing the cat­tle walk out to graze, and each evening they come home. The herder has no words for num­bers and no writ­ten numer­als. How can the herder tell whether a calf is lost?

A sim­ple trick works. As each cow leaves, drop one peb­ble into a pot. As each cow returns, take one peb­ble out. If the pot ends up empty, every cow is home. If some peb­bles are left, that many cows are miss­ing. Pair­ing each cow with exactly one peb­ble is called one-to-one cor­re­spon­dence. You do not need to know the word "four­teen" to use it; you only need to match things up.

This match­ing idea is where the nat­ural num­bers come from:

N={1,2,3,4,…}\mathbb{N} = \{1, 2, 3, 4, \ldots\}

Worked exam­ple 1

A goatherd puts one peb­ble in a pot for each goat that goes out in the morn­ing, 23 peb­bles in all. In the evening one peb­ble is removed for each goat that returns, and 21 peb­bles are removed. What does the pot tell the goatherd?

Each return­ing goat can­cels one peb­ble, so the peb­bles still in the pot stand for goats that have not come back.

23−21=223 - 21 = 2

Two peb­bles remain, so two goats are still miss­ing.

Num­bers carved in bone

The chap­ter tells us that the old­est phys­i­cal records of count­ing are tally marks cut into bone, found in Africa. The Lebombo bone, from the Lebombo Moun­tains between South Africa and Swazi­land, is about 35,000 years old and car­ries 29 neat notches of equal size. Researchers think it may have been used to fol­low the phases of the Moon, a way of track­ing time with nat­ural num­bers.

The Ishango bone, found near the source of the Nile in the Demo­c­ra­tic Repub­lic of Congo, dates to around 20,000 BCE. It has three columns of notches. One col­umn holds groups of 11, 13, 17 and 19 notches. These are exactly the prime num­bers between 10 and 20, the num­bers whose only fac­tors are 1 and them­selves. Another col­umn seems to show dou­bling. So the idea of a num­ber is tens of thou­sands of years old.

Four rows of vertical tally marks with 11, 13, 17 and 19 strokes, each labelled as a prime whose only factors are 1 and itself
Tally groups of 11, 13, 17 and 19: the four primes between 10 and 20, like the groups on one col­umn of the Ishango bone.

Is sub­trac­tion always pos­si­ble with nat­ural num­bers?

Add two nat­ural num­bers and you always get a nat­ural num­ber: 4+9=134 + 9 = 13. We say the nat­ural num­bers are closed under addi­tion. Sub­trac­tion is dif­fer­ent. 9−4=59 - 4 = 5 is fine, but 3−53 - 5 has no answer among 1,2,3,…1, 2, 3, \ldots, and nei­ther does 5−55 - 5. So the nat­ural num­bers are not closed under sub­trac­tion. This gap is exactly what zero and the neg­a­tive num­bers will fill.

Large num­bers in the Indian tra­di­tion

Trade needed care­ful count­ing

In cities of the Indus Val­ley Civil­i­sa­tion, such as Lothal and Harappa, weights and mea­sures were stan­dard­ised. Mer­chants who traded pot­tery, lapis lazuli or cot­ton with Mesopotamia needed reli­able ways to count and keep accounts.

Names for pow­ers of ten

Thinkers of the Vedic period were fas­ci­nated by very large num­bers. The Vedas give names to every power of 10 up to 101210^{12}, which was called parārdha. In the Lal­i­tavis­tara, Bud­dha names num­bers up to 105310^{53}, called tal­lakṣhaṇa. The Ṛigveda already expressed quan­ti­ties using pow­ers of 10. This habit pre­pared the ground for the place-value sys­tem based on pow­ers of 10 that grew up in India and is now used all over the world, and it helped lead to the idea of zero.

Worked exam­ple 2

How many times larger is tal­lakṣhaṇa than parārdha?

10531012=1053−12=1041\displaystyle \frac{10^{53}}{10^{12}} = 10^{53-12} = 10^{41}

Tal­lakṣhaṇa is 104110^{41} times parārdha: a 1 fol­lowed by 41 zeros.

Count­ing on fin­ger joints

A prac­tice still seen in India is to count with the thumb on the joints of the other four fin­gers of the same hand. Each fin­ger has 3 joints, so one hand counts 4×3=124 \times 3 = 12. This is one nat­ural way a count­ing sys­tem built on twelves (base 12) could arise.

Zero: when noth­ing became a num­ber

A place­holder is not yet a num­ber

For a very long time the num­ber line began at 1. If you gave away all five of your apples, you had no num­ber for what you held. The Baby­lo­ni­ans and the Mayans used a mark to show an empty place inside a writ­ten num­ber, but they did not add, sub­tract or mul­ti­ply with "noth­ing".

From śhūny­atā to śhūnya

In the Upan­ishads and in Bud­dhist writ­ings, śhūny­atā (empti­ness) was a state sought through yoga and med­i­ta­tion: a mind emp­tied of all vṛt­tis, its rest­less move­ments. The word śhūnya means zero. Patan­jal­i's Yoga Sutras also describe how this empti­ness helps con­trol mind, body and senses. Because Indian thinkers val­ued empti­ness, they were ready to accept "noth­ing" as a real idea. The idea trav­elled into archi­tec­ture, lit­er­a­ture and lin­guis­tics, and then into math­e­mat­ics in the work of Āryab­haṭa and finally Brah­magupta.

The Bakhśhālī Man­u­script, dated by the book to the early cen­turies CE, uses a bold dot (bindu) for zero. A sym­bol, how­ever, becomes a num­ber only when it has rules.

Brah­magup­ta's rules for zero

In his Brāh­mas­phuṭasid­dhānta (628 CE), Brah­magupta defined zero as what you get when a num­ber is taken away from itself, a−a=0a - a = 0. He then stated how zero behaves:

  • Adding zero changes noth­ing: a+0=aa + 0 = a.
  • Sub­tract­ing zero changes noth­ing: a−0=aa - 0 = a.
  • Mul­ti­ply­ing by zero gives zero: a×0=0a \times 0 = 0.

For exam­ple, 48+0=4848 + 0 = 48, 48−0=4848 - 0 = 48 and 48×0=048 \times 0 = 0. With these rules, zero is a num­ber you can cal­cu­late with, not just an empty place.

Inte­gers: num­bers to the left of zero

For­tunes and debts

If 5−5=05 - 5 = 0, what is 3−53 - 5? Brah­magupta answered with ideas from trade. He spoke of two kinds of quan­tity:

  • Dhana (for­tune): pos­i­tive num­bers, like money you own.
  • Ṛiṇa (debt): neg­a­tive num­bers, like money you owe.

So 3−5=−23 - 5 = -2: if you have ₹3 and must pay ₹5, you end up owing ₹2. The neg­a­tive num­bers sit to the left of zero on the num­ber line. Putting together the pos­i­tive whole num­bers, their neg­a­tives and zero gives the inte­gers:

Z={…,−3,−2,−1,0,1,2,3,…}\mathbb{Z} = \{\ldots, -3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, 3, \ldots\}

The let­ter Z\mathbb{Z} comes from the Ger­man word Zahlen, mean­ing "num­bers". The inte­gers are closed under sub­trac­tion: the dif­fer­ence of any two inte­gers is again an inte­ger.

Brah­magup­ta's rules for inte­gers

Brah­magup­ta's rules are the ones we still use:

  1. For­tune plus for­tune is for­tune: 5+4=95 + 4 = 9.
  2. Debt plus debt is debt: (−5)+(−4)=−9(-5) + (-4) = -9. Owe ₹5, bor­row ₹4 more, and you owe ₹9.
  3. For­tune minus zero is for­tune; debt minus zero is debt: 7−0=77 - 0 = 7 and −6−0=−6-6 - 0 = -6.
  4. Debt times for­tune is debt: (−3)×4=−12(-3) \times 4 = -12. Four debts of ₹3 each make a debt of ₹12.
  5. Debt times debt is for­tune: (−3)×(−4)=12(-3) \times (-4) = 12.
Integer number line from minus 10 to 10 with negatives marked as debts and positives as fortunes; jumps of minus 5 then minus 4 end at minus 9
Adding two debts on the num­ber line: start at 0, move 5 left, then 4 more left, land­ing on −9-9.

Worked exam­ple 3

(a) Find (−7)+(−6)(-7) + (-6). (b) A shop­keeper has ₹9 in the drawer and must pay a bill of ₹14. What is her posi­tion?

(a) Two debts add to a big­ger debt: (−7)+(−6)=−13(-7) + (-6) = -13.

(b) The for­tune is +9+9 and the bill is a debt of 1414:

9+(−14)=−(14−9)=−59 + (-14) = -(14 - 9) = -5

She is ₹5 in debt. When a for­tune and a debt are com­bined, take the dif­fer­ence of their sizes and give it the sign of the one with the larger size.

Why is a debt times a debt a for­tune?

The book asks us to think of mul­ti­ply­ing by a neg­a­tive num­ber as remov­ing. Sup­pose you have four debts of ₹3 each. If some­one takes away those four debts, you are ₹12 bet­ter off than before. Tak­ing away (the "−-") four debts of −3-3 gives +12+12:

(−3)×(−4)=+12(-3) \times (-4) = +12

A pat­tern gives the same answer. Look at mul­ti­ples of −2-2 as the sec­ond num­ber goes down by 1 each time:

(−2)×3=−6(−2)×2=−4(−2)×1=−2(−2)×0=0(−2)×(−1)= ?\begin{aligned} (-2) \times 3 &= -6 \\ (-2) \times 2 &= -4 \\ (-2) \times 1 &= -2 \\ (-2) \times 0 &= 0 \\ (-2) \times (-1) &= \ ? \end{aligned}

Each answer is 2 more than the one above it. To keep the pat­tern going, (−2)×(−1)(-2) \times (-1) must be 0+2=20 + 2 = 2, and (−2)×(−2)(-2) \times (-2) must be 44. Any other choice would break the rules we already trust.

Worked exam­ple 4

Work out (a) (−6)×(−5)(-6) \times (-5), (b) (−8)×3(-8) \times 3, (c) 0×(−9)0 \times (-9), (d) 15−(−4)15 - (-4).

(a) Debt times debt is for­tune: (−6)×(−5)=30(-6) \times (-5) = 30.

(b) Debt times for­tune is debt: (−8)×3=−24(-8) \times 3 = -24.

(c) Any­thing times zero is zero: 0×(−9)=00 \times (-9) = 0.

(d) Sub­tract­ing a debt means a debt is taken away from you. If you have ₹15 and some­one can­cels a ₹4 debt you owed, you are ₹4 richer. So sub­tract­ing −4-4 is the same as adding 44:

15−(−4)=15+4=1915 - (-4) = 15 + 4 = 19

Worked exam­ple 5

At dawn the tem­per­a­ture in Dras is −3 ∘C-3\,^\circ\text{C}. By night it has fallen by 12 ∘C12\,^\circ\text{C}. The next after­noon it is 20 ∘C20\,^\circ\text{C} higher than that night read­ing. Find both tem­per­a­tures.

Night: −3−12=−15 ∘CAfternoon: −15+20=5 ∘C\begin{aligned} \text{Night: } -3 - 12 &= -15\,^\circ\text{C} \\ \text{Afternoon: } -15 + 20 &= 5\,^\circ\text{C} \end{aligned}

A fall is a move to the left on the num­ber line; a rise is a move to the right.

Divi­sion of inte­gers

Divi­sion undoes mul­ti­pli­ca­tion, so its sign rules match. Since (−3)×4=−12(-3) \times 4 = -12, we get (−12)÷4=−3(-12) \div 4 = -3 and (−12)÷(−3)=4(-12) \div (-3) = 4. Like signs give a pos­i­tive quo­tient; unlike signs give a neg­a­tive one.

Com­mon mis­takes

  • Writ­ing (−5)+(−4)=9(-5) + (-4) = 9 or −1-1. Two debts always make a larger debt: the answer is −9-9.
  • Think­ing (−3)×(−4)=−12(-3) \times (-4) = -12 "because both are neg­a­tive". The prod­uct of two neg­a­tives is pos­i­tive.
  • Read­ing 10−(−5)10 - (-5) as 10−510 - 5. Sub­tract­ing a neg­a­tive adds: 10−(−5)=1510 - (-5) = 15.
  • Believ­ing zero is a nat­ural num­ber. In this chap­ter N\mathbb{N} starts at 1; zero joins with the inte­gers.
  • Say­ing a×0=aa \times 0 = a. Adding zero leaves a num­ber unchanged, but mul­ti­ply­ing by zero gives zero.
  • Assum­ing nat­ural num­bers are closed under sub­trac­tion. 3−53 - 5 is not a nat­ural num­ber.

Try these

  1. Find (−9)+(−8)(-9) + (-8). Answer: −17-17
  2. Find (−4)×(−11)(-4) \times (-11). Answer: 4444
  3. Find 6−(−9)6 - (-9). Answer: 1515
  4. A pot­ter bor­rows ₹700, then earns ₹950, then loses ₹300. Find the final posi­tion. Answer: −700+950−300=−50-700 + 950 - 300 = -50, a debt of ₹50
  5. A herder drops a peb­ble for each of 14 cows going out and removes one for each of 11 return­ing. How many peb­bles remain, and what do they mean? Answer: 3 peb­bles; 3 cows are miss­ing
  6. Which primes lie between 20 and 30? Answer: 23 and 29

Key terms

One-to-one cor­re­spon­dence
Pair­ing each object of one group with exactly one object of another group, as with cows and peb­bles.
Nat­ural num­bers
The count­ing num­bers 1,2,3,…1, 2, 3, \ldots, writ­ten N\mathbb{N}.
Prime num­ber
A nat­ural num­ber greater than 1 whose only fac­tors are 1 and itself, such as 11, 13, 17 and 19.
Clo­sure
A set is closed under an oper­a­tion if doing that oper­a­tion on any two of its mem­bers always gives a mem­ber of the same set.
Śhūnya
The San­skrit word for zero; śhūny­atā means empti­ness.
Dhana and ṛiṇa
Brah­magup­ta's names for for­tunes (pos­i­tive num­bers) and debts (neg­a­tive num­bers).
Inte­gers
The whole num­bers together with their neg­a­tives and zero, writ­ten Z\mathbb{Z}.
Parārdha
The Vedic name for 101210^{12}.

Com­mon ques­tions

Is zero pos­i­tive or neg­a­tive?

Nei­ther. Zero is the divid­ing point of the num­ber line: pos­i­tive inte­gers lie to its right and neg­a­tive inte­gers to its left.

Who first treated zero as a num­ber?

Accord­ing to the chap­ter, Brah­magupta, in the Brāh­mas­phuṭasid­dhānta (628 CE), defined zero as a−aa - a and gave rules for adding, sub­tract­ing and mul­ti­ply­ing with it.

Why is sub­tract­ing a neg­a­tive the same as adding?

Sub­tract­ing a debt means a debt is can­celled, which leaves you richer by that amount. So 10−(−5)=10+5=1510 - (-5) = 10 + 5 = 15.

Why is the set of inte­gers called Z?

The let­ter comes from the Ger­man word Zahlen, which means num­bers.

What was spe­cial about the Ishango bone?

One col­umn of its notches is grouped as 11, 13, 17 and 19, the primes between 10 and 20, and another col­umn seems to show dou­bling.

Ref­er­ences

  1. National Coun­cil of Edu­ca­tional Research and Train­ing. Ganita Man­jari: Text­book of Math­e­mat­ics, Grade 9 (Part I). NCERT, New Delhi.
  2. Bur­ton, D. M. Ele­men­tary Num­ber The­ory. McGraw-Hill Edu­ca­tion.
  3. Gelfand, I. M. and Shen, A. Alge­bra. Birkhäuser.