The third method, cross multiplication, needs no choices at all. You do not decide which variable to make the subject or which to eliminate: you write the six coefficients in a fixed pattern, multiply across, and read off both answers at once. It is a formula, and like any formula it is fast once you know it and dangerous if you mix up a sign, so work slowly at first.
Getting the equations ready
Cross multiplication needs both equations in general form, with everything on the left and 0 on the right:
a1x+b1y+c1a2x+b2y+c2=0(1)=0(2)
So 3x+2y=5 must first become 3x+2y−5=0, which makes c1=−5, not 5. Getting the sign of c wrong is the most common mistake with this method.
The pattern
Write the coefficients in two rows in this order: b, c, a, b. The b column appears twice, at the start and at the end.
Now take the columns in neighbouring pairs and cross multiply each pair: the product down to the right minus the product up to the right.
- Columns b, c give b1c2−b2c1. This goes under x.
- Columns c, a give c1a2−c2a1. This goes under y.
- Columns a, b give a1b2−a2b1. This goes under 1.
The rule is
b1c2−b2c1x=c1a2−c2a1y=a1b2−a2b11
From it, x=a1b2−a2b1b1c2−b2c1 and y=a1b2−a2b1c1a2−c2a1.
Example 1
Solve 3x+2y=5 and 2x−3y=7 by cross multiplication.
In general form:
3x+2y−52x−3y−7=0(1)=0(2)
So a1=3, b1=2, c1=−5 and a2=2, b2=−3, c2=−7. The pattern is
Cross multiply each neighbouring pair of columns:
- under x: (2)(−7)−(−3)(−5)=−14−15=−29
- under y: (−5)(2)−(−7)(3)=−10+21=11
- under 1: (3)(−3)−(2)(2)=−9−4=−13
−29x=11y=−131
So x=−13−29=1329 and y=−1311=−1311.
∴(x,y)=(1329,−1311)
This is the same answer the substitution and elimination methods gave. Three methods, one answer.
Example 2
Solve 7x−5y=2 and x+2y=3 by cross multiplication.
7x−5y−2x+2y−3=0(1)=0(2)
- under x: (−5)(−3)−(2)(−2)=15+4=19
- under y: (−2)(1)−(−3)(7)=−2+21=19
- under 1: (7)(2)−(1)(−5)=14+5=19
19x=19y=191
So x=1919=1 and y=1919=1.
∴(x,y)=(1,1)
Example 3
Solve 2x−3y=4 and 5x+2y=1 by cross multiplication.
2x−3y−45x+2y−1=0(1)=0(2)
- under x: (−3)(−1)−(2)(−4)=3+8=11
- under y: (−4)(5)−(−1)(2)=−20+2=−18
- under 1: (2)(2)−(5)(−3)=4+15=19
11x=−18y=191
∴(x,y)=(1911,−1918)
This matches the answer found by elimination in the last lesson.
When the method breaks down
The number under 1 is a1b2−a2b1. If it is 0, you would be dividing by zero, and the method gives no answer. But a1b2−a2b1=0 means exactly that a2a1=b2b1: the lines are parallel or the same line, so there is no unique solution to find. This links straight back to the conditions in the second lesson of this chapter.
Which method should you use?
- Substitution when one variable has coefficient 1 or −1.
- Elimination for most pairs worked by hand, especially when a small multiplier makes the coefficients match.
- Cross multiplication when the numbers are awkward, or when you want both answers from one formula. It is also an excellent way to check an answer found by another method.
Practice
Solve each pair by cross multiplication.
- x+2y−7=0 and 2x−y−4=0
- 3x+y−5=0 and x−2y+3=0
- 2x+3y=13 and 3x−y=3
- 4x−3y=5 and 2x+y=5
- 5x+2y=3 and 3x+4y=−1
- 3x−5y=4 and 2x+3y=1
- x−y+1=0 and 3x+2y−18=0
- Show that cross multiplication gives no answer for 2x+4y−3=0, x+2y−5=0, and say what that means.
- Two kilograms of apples and three kilograms of bananas cost ₹380. Three kilograms of apples and one kilogram of bananas cost ₹430. Find the price of one kilogram of each.
Answers
Show answers
- Under x: (2)(−4)−(−1)(−7)=−15. Under y: (−7)(2)−(−4)(1)=−10. Under 1: (1)(−1)−(2)(2)=−5. So x=3, y=2.
- Under x: (1)(3)−(−2)(−5)=−7. Under y: (−5)(1)−(3)(3)=−14. Under 1: (3)(−2)−(1)(1)=−7. So x=1, y=2.
- With c1=−13, c2=−3: under x −22, under y −33, under 1 −11. So x=2, y=3.
- With c1=−5, c2=−5: under x 20, under y 10, under 1 10. So x=2, y=1.
- With c1=−3, c2=1: under x 14, under y −14, under 1 14. So x=1, y=−1.
- With c1=−4, c2=−1: under x 17, under y −5, under 1 19. So x=1917, y=−195.
- Under x: (−1)(−18)−(2)(1)=16. Under y: (1)(3)−(−18)(1)=21. Under 1: (1)(2)−(3)(−1)=5. So x=516, y=521.
- Under 1: (2)(2)−(1)(4)=0, so the method would divide by zero. Here 12=24 but −5−3=53, so the lines are parallel and the pair has no solution.
- Apples x, bananas y rupees a kilogram: 2x+3y−380=0 and 3x+y−430=0. Under x −910, under y −280, under 1 −7. So apples cost ₹130 a kilogram and bananas ₹40.