The third method, cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion, needs no choices at all. You do not decide which vari­able to make the sub­ject or which to elim­i­nate: you write the six coef­fi­cients in a fixed pat­tern, mul­ti­ply across, and read off both answers at once. It is a for­mula, and like any for­mula it is fast once you know it and dan­ger­ous if you mix up a sign, so work slowly at first.

Get­ting the equa­tions ready

Cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion needs both equa­tions in gen­eral form, with every­thing on the left and 00 on the right:

a1x+b1y+c1=0(1)a2x+b2y+c2=0(2)\begin{aligned} a_1x + b_1y + c_1 &= 0 \quad \text{(1)} \\ a_2x + b_2y + c_2 &= 0 \quad \text{(2)} \end{aligned}

So 3x+2y=53x + 2y = 5 must first become 3x+2y−5=03x + 2y - 5 = 0, which makes c1=−5c_1 = -5, not 55. Get­ting the sign of cc wrong is the most com­mon mis­take with this method.

The pat­tern

Write the coef­fi­cients in two rows in this order: bb, cc, aa, bb. The bb col­umn appears twice, at the start and at the end.

bb cc aa bb
b1b_1 c1c_1 a1a_1 b1b_1
b2b_2 c2c_2 a2a_2 b2b_2

Now take the columns in neigh­bour­ing pairs and cross mul­ti­ply each pair: the prod­uct down to the right minus the prod­uct up to the right.

  • Columns bb, cc give b1c2−b2c1b_1c_2 - b_2c_1. This goes under xx.
  • Columns cc, aa give c1a2−c2a1c_1a_2 - c_2a_1. This goes under yy.
  • Columns aa, bb give a1b2−a2b1a_1b_2 - a_2b_1. This goes under 11.

The rule is

xb1c2−b2c1=yc1a2−c2a1=1a1b2−a2b1\displaystyle \frac{x}{b_1c_2 - b_2c_1} = \frac{y}{c_1a_2 - c_2a_1} = \frac{1}{a_1b_2 - a_2b_1}

From it, x=b1c2−b2c1a1b2−a2b1\displaystyle x = \dfrac{b_1c_2 - b_2c_1}{a_1b_2 - a_2b_1} and y=c1a2−c2a1a1b2−a2b1\displaystyle y = \dfrac{c_1a_2 - c_2a_1}{a_1b_2 - a_2b_1}.

Exam­ple 1

Solve 3x+2y=53x + 2y = 5 and 2x−3y=72x - 3y = 7 by cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion.

In gen­eral form:

3x+2y−5=0(1)2x−3y−7=0(2)\begin{aligned} 3x + 2y - 5 &= 0 \quad \text{(1)} \\ 2x - 3y - 7 &= 0 \quad \text{(2)} \end{aligned}

So a1=3a_1 = 3, b1=2b_1 = 2, c1=−5c_1 = -5 and a2=2a_2 = 2, b2=−3b_2 = -3, c2=−7c_2 = -7. The pat­tern is

bb cc aa bb
22 −5-5 33 22
−3-3 −7-7 22 −3-3

Cross mul­ti­ply each neigh­bour­ing pair of columns:

  • under xx: (2)(−7)−(−3)(−5)=−14−15=−29(2)(-7) - (-3)(-5) = -14 - 15 = -29
  • under yy: (−5)(2)−(−7)(3)=−10+21=11(-5)(2) - (-7)(3) = -10 + 21 = 11
  • under 11: (3)(−3)−(2)(2)=−9−4=−13(3)(-3) - (2)(2) = -9 - 4 = -13

x−29=y11=1−13\displaystyle \frac{x}{-29} = \frac{y}{11} = \frac{1}{-13}

So x=−29−13=2913\displaystyle x = \frac{-29}{-13} = \frac{29}{13} and y=11−13=−1113\displaystyle y = \frac{11}{-13} = -\frac{11}{13}.

∴(x,y)=(2913,−1113)\displaystyle \therefore (x, y) = \left(\frac{29}{13}, -\frac{11}{13}\right)

This is the same answer the sub­sti­tu­tion and elim­i­na­tion meth­ods gave. Three meth­ods, one answer.

Exam­ple 2

Solve 7x−5y=27x - 5y = 2 and x+2y=3x + 2y = 3 by cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion.

7x−5y−2=0(1)x+2y−3=0(2)\begin{aligned} 7x - 5y - 2 &= 0 \quad \text{(1)} \\ x + 2y - 3 &= 0 \quad \text{(2)} \end{aligned}

bb cc aa bb
−5-5 −2-2 77 −5-5
22 −3-3 11 22
  • under xx: (−5)(−3)−(2)(−2)=15+4=19(-5)(-3) - (2)(-2) = 15 + 4 = 19
  • under yy: (−2)(1)−(−3)(7)=−2+21=19(-2)(1) - (-3)(7) = -2 + 21 = 19
  • under 11: (7)(2)−(1)(−5)=14+5=19(7)(2) - (1)(-5) = 14 + 5 = 19

x19=y19=119\displaystyle \frac{x}{19} = \frac{y}{19} = \frac{1}{19}

So x=1919=1\displaystyle x = \frac{19}{19} = 1 and y=1919=1\displaystyle y = \frac{19}{19} = 1.

∴(x,y)=(1,1)\therefore (x, y) = (1, 1)

Exam­ple 3

Solve 2x−3y=42x - 3y = 4 and 5x+2y=15x + 2y = 1 by cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion.

2x−3y−4=0(1)5x+2y−1=0(2)\begin{aligned} 2x - 3y - 4 &= 0 \quad \text{(1)} \\ 5x + 2y - 1 &= 0 \quad \text{(2)} \end{aligned}

bb cc aa bb
−3-3 −4-4 22 −3-3
22 −1-1 55 22
  • under xx: (−3)(−1)−(2)(−4)=3+8=11(-3)(-1) - (2)(-4) = 3 + 8 = 11
  • under yy: (−4)(5)−(−1)(2)=−20+2=−18(-4)(5) - (-1)(2) = -20 + 2 = -18
  • under 11: (2)(2)−(5)(−3)=4+15=19(2)(2) - (5)(-3) = 4 + 15 = 19

x11=y−18=119\displaystyle \frac{x}{11} = \frac{y}{-18} = \frac{1}{19}

∴(x,y)=(1119,−1819)\displaystyle \therefore (x, y) = \left(\frac{11}{19}, -\frac{18}{19}\right)

This matches the answer found by elim­i­na­tion in the last les­son.

When the method breaks down

The num­ber under 11 is a1b2−a2b1a_1b_2 - a_2b_1. If it is 00, you would be divid­ing by zero, and the method gives no answer. But a1b2−a2b1=0a_1b_2 - a_2b_1 = 0 means exactly that a1a2=b1b2\displaystyle \frac{a_1}{a_2} = \frac{b_1}{b_2}: the lines are par­al­lel or the same line, so there is no unique solu­tion to find. This links straight back to the con­di­tions in the sec­ond les­son of this chap­ter.

Which method should you use?

  • Sub­sti­tu­tion when one vari­able has coef­fi­cient 11 or −1-1.
  • Elim­i­na­tion for most pairs worked by hand, espe­cially when a small mul­ti­plier makes the coef­fi­cients match.
  • Cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion when the num­bers are awk­ward, or when you want both answers from one for­mula. It is also an excel­lent way to check an answer found by another method.

Prac­tice

Solve each pair by cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion.

  1. x+2y−7=0x + 2y - 7 = 0 and 2x−y−4=02x - y - 4 = 0
  2. 3x+y−5=03x + y - 5 = 0 and x−2y+3=0x - 2y + 3 = 0
  3. 2x+3y=132x + 3y = 13 and 3x−y=33x - y = 3
  4. 4x−3y=54x - 3y = 5 and 2x+y=52x + y = 5
  5. 5x+2y=35x + 2y = 3 and 3x+4y=−13x + 4y = -1
  6. 3x−5y=43x - 5y = 4 and 2x+3y=12x + 3y = 1
  7. x−y+1=0x - y + 1 = 0 and 3x+2y−18=03x + 2y - 18 = 0
  8. Show that cross mul­ti­pli­ca­tion gives no answer for 2x+4y−3=02x + 4y - 3 = 0, x+2y−5=0x + 2y - 5 = 0, and say what that means.
  9. Two kilo­grams of apples and three kilo­grams of bananas cost ₹380. Three kilo­grams of apples and one kilo­gram of bananas cost ₹430. Find the price of one kilo­gram of each.

Answers

Show answers
  1. Under xx: (2)(−4)−(−1)(−7)=−15(2)(-4) - (-1)(-7) = -15. Under yy: (−7)(2)−(−4)(1)=−10(-7)(2) - (-4)(1) = -10. Under 11: (1)(−1)−(2)(2)=−5(1)(-1) - (2)(2) = -5. So x=3x = 3, y=2y = 2.
  2. Under xx: (1)(3)−(−2)(−5)=−7(1)(3) - (-2)(-5) = -7. Under yy: (−5)(1)−(3)(3)=−14(-5)(1) - (3)(3) = -14. Under 11: (3)(−2)−(1)(1)=−7(3)(-2) - (1)(1) = -7. So x=1x = 1, y=2y = 2.
  3. With c1=−13c_1 = -13, c2=−3c_2 = -3: under xx −22-22, under yy −33-33, under 11 −11-11. So x=2x = 2, y=3y = 3.
  4. With c1=−5c_1 = -5, c2=−5c_2 = -5: under xx 2020, under yy 1010, under 11 1010. So x=2x = 2, y=1y = 1.
  5. With c1=−3c_1 = -3, c2=1c_2 = 1: under xx 1414, under yy −14-14, under 11 1414. So x=1x = 1, y=−1y = -1.
  6. With c1=−4c_1 = -4, c2=−1c_2 = -1: under xx 1717, under yy −5-5, under 11 1919. So x=1719\displaystyle x = \frac{17}{19}, y=−519\displaystyle y = -\frac{5}{19}.
  7. Under xx: (−1)(−18)−(2)(1)=16(-1)(-18) - (2)(1) = 16. Under yy: (1)(3)−(−18)(1)=21(1)(3) - (-18)(1) = 21. Under 11: (1)(2)−(3)(−1)=5(1)(2) - (3)(-1) = 5. So x=165\displaystyle x = \frac{16}{5}, y=215\displaystyle y = \frac{21}{5}.
  8. Under 11: (2)(2)−(1)(4)=0(2)(2) - (1)(4) = 0, so the method would divide by zero. Here 21=42\displaystyle \frac{2}{1} = \frac{4}{2} but −3−5=35\displaystyle \frac{-3}{-5} = \frac{3}{5}, so the lines are par­al­lel and the pair has no solu­tion.
  9. Apples xx, bananas yy rupees a kilo­gram: 2x+3y−380=02x + 3y - 380 = 0 and 3x+y−430=03x + y - 430 = 0. Under xx −910-910, under yy −280-280, under 11 −7-7. So apples cost ₹130 a kilo­gram and bananas ₹40.