Where we are going

You already know how to square a num­ber. Now we run the film back­wards: if you know the area of a square, can you find its side? That is what a square root does. You will see three ways to find one (list­ing, sub­tract­ing odd num­bers, and prime fac­tori­sa­tion), and a way to esti­mate a root when the num­ber is not a per­fect square. Then we do the same for cubes and cube roots, meet the famous taxi­cab num­ber 17291729, and fin­ish with the story behind the words square, cube and root.

Square roots

If y=x2y = x^2, then xx is a square root of yy. Think of a square tile of area 121121 cm². Its side must be 1111 cm, because 112=12111^2 = 121.

An 11 by 11 grid of unit squares forming a large square, each side labelled 11 cm and the whole marked as area 121 square centimetres.
A square of area 121 cm² has side 11 cm

Every pos­i­tive per­fect square actu­ally has two inte­ger square roots, since 112=12111^2 = 121 and (−11)2=121(-11)^2 = 121 as well. The sym­bol  \sqrt{\ } always means the pos­i­tive one, so 121=11\sqrt{121} = 11. In this chap­ter we work only with pos­i­tive roots.

Is it a square, and what is its root?

Method 1, list­ing. Sup­pose you want to test 784784. Walk up the squares: 252=62525^2 = 625, 262=67626^2 = 676, 272=72927^2 = 729, 282=78428^2 = 784. So 784=28\sqrt{784} = 28. It works, but it gets slow for big num­bers.

Method 2, sub­tract­ing odd num­bers. Take 144\sqrt{144}. Keep tak­ing away odd num­bers in order: 144−1−3−5−7−9−11−13−15−17−19−21−23=0144 - 1 - 3 - 5 - 7 - 9 - 11 - 13 - 15 - 17 - 19 - 21 - 23 = 0. You reach zero after twelve sub­trac­tions, so 144=12\sqrt{144} = 12. It never lets you down, though it becomes tir­ing once the num­ber runs into a few hun­dred.

Method 3, prime fac­tori­sa­tion. This is the one you will use most. The prime fac­tors of a per­fect square always split into two iden­ti­cal groups.

900=2×2×3×3×5×5=(2×3×5)×(2×3×5)=302900 = 2 \times 2 \times 3 \times 3 \times 5 \times 5 = (2 \times 3 \times 5) \times (2 \times 3 \times 5) = 30^2

so 900=30\sqrt{900} = 30. Look at the pairs, (2×2)(3×3)(5×5)(2 \times 2)(3 \times 3)(5 \times 5): every prime turns up an even num­ber of times.

Now try 540=22×33×5540 = 2^2 \times 3^3 \times 5. Here the 33 appears three times and the 55 only once, so 540540 can­not be a square. But we can repair it. Mul­ti­ply by 3×5=153 \times 5 = 15 and every prime is paired: 540×15=8100=902540 \times 15 = 8100 = 90^2.

Exam­ple 1. Is 17641764 a square? Fac­torise: 1764=22×32×72=(2×3×7)2=4221764 = 2^2 \times 3^2 \times 7^2 = (2 \times 3 \times 7)^2 = 42^2. Yes, and 1764=42\sqrt{1764} = 42.

Exam­ple 2. Find the small­est square divis­i­ble by 66, 88 and 1515. Start with the LCM, 120=23×3×5120 = 2^3 \times 3 \times 5. To make every expo­nent even, mul­ti­ply by 2×3×5=302 \times 3 \times 5 = 30. That gives 3600=6023600 = 60^2.

Esti­mat­ing a square root

Here is a neat bit of detec­tive work. Take 2209\sqrt{2209}. It sits between 402=160040^2 = 1600 and 502=250050^2 = 2500. The last digit is 99, so the root must end in 33 or 77, which means 4343 or 4747. Since 452=2025<220945^2 = 2025 < 2209, the root is above 4545, so it is 4747. Always check: 472=220947^2 = 2209 ✓.

When the num­ber is not a square, you can still trap it between two neigh­bours. For 300\sqrt{300}: 172=28917^2 = 289 and 182=32418^2 = 324, so 17<300<1817 < \sqrt{300} < 18, and it is nearer 1717.

Number line from 289 to 324 marking 289 as 17 squared, 300, and 324 as 18 squared; 300 is 11 above 289 and 24 below 324, so root 300 lies nearer 17.
The square root of 300 lies between 17 and 18, nearer 17

Exam­ple 3. You have a square sheet of area 200200 cm² and want to cut out the largest square with a whole-num­ber side. Since 142=196≤200<225=15214^2 = 196 \leq 200 < 225 = 15^2, the answer is 1414 cm.

Cubes

Now step up from flat squares to solid blocks. A cube of edge nn is built from nn lay­ers, each with n×nn \times n unit cubes, so it holds n×n×n=n3n \times n \times n = n^3 of them. The per­fect cubes are 1,8,27,64,125,216,343,512,729,1000,…1, 8, 27, 64, 125, 216, 343, 512, 729, 1000, \ldots

A cube of edge 3 drawn as 27 small unit cubes in three layers of 3 by 3, with the top layer of 9 shaded darker than the two layers below it.
A cube of edge 3: three lay­ers of 9 unit cubes

Unlike squares, cubes can end in any digit. If a num­ber ends in dd, its cube ends in the last digit of d3d^3, which gives 0,1,8,7,4,5,6,3,2,90, 1, 8, 7, 4, 5, 6, 3, 2, 9 for d=0d = 0 to 99. Each last digit turns up exactly once, so the last digit of a cube tells you straight away the last digit of its root. Keep this in your pocket. Also, a cube ends in 3k3k zeros, never in exactly two.

There are only two two-digit cubes, 2727 and 6464. The three-digit ones are 125,216,343,512,729125, 216, 343, 512, 729. And the cube of a two-digit num­ber has some­where between four (103=100010^3 = 1000) and six (993=97029999^3 = 970299) dig­its.

Frac­tions and neg­a­tive num­bers behave just as you would expect: (35)3=27125\displaystyle \left(\frac{3}{5}\right)^3 = \frac{27}{125} and (−4)3=−64(-4)^3 = -64. An odd num­ber cubed stays odd.

Cubes from odd num­bers

Look at this lovely pat­tern:

1=1,3+5=8,7+9+11=27,13+15+17+19=641 = 1, \quad 3 + 5 = 8, \quad 7 + 9 + 11 = 27, \quad 13 + 15 + 17 + 19 = 64

The nn-th cube is the sum of nn con­sec­u­tive odd num­bers, each group pick­ing up where the last one stopped. So the eighth group, 57+59+⋯+7157 + 59 + \cdots + 71, has to be 83=5128^3 = 512. You don't even need to add it up.

The taxi­cab num­ber

There is a well-loved story here. Hardy went to see Ramanu­jan in hos­pi­tal and said the num­ber of his taxi, 17291729, seemed rather dull. Ramanu­jan answered at once that it was the small­est num­ber that can be writ­ten as a sum of two cubes in two dif­fer­ent ways:

1729=13+123=93+1031729 = 1^3 + 12^3 = 9^3 + 10^3

Num­bers like this are now called taxi­cab num­bers. The next one is 4104=23+163=93+1534104 = 2^3 + 16^3 = 9^3 + 15^3.

Cube roots

Undo­ing a cube works the same way. If y=x3y = x^3, then x=y3x = \sqrt[3]{y}. For exam­ple, 3433=7\sqrt[3]{343} = 7.

With prime fac­tori­sa­tion, a per­fect cube's fac­tors split into three iden­ti­cal groups, so every prime must appear a mul­ti­ple of three times.

5832=23×36=(2×32)3=183,58323=185832 = 2^3 \times 3^6 = (2 \times 3^2)^3 = 18^3, \qquad \sqrt[3]{5832} = 18

Now take 1080=23×33×51080 = 2^3 \times 3^3 \times 5. That sin­gle 55 spoils it. Mul­ti­ply by 2525 and you get 27000=30327000 = 30^3.

Guess­ing from the dig­its. Try 21973\sqrt[3]{2197}. The last digit 77 tells you the root ends in 33. Since 103=1000<2197<8000=20310^3 = 1000 < 2197 < 8000 = 20^3, the root must be 1313. Check: 133=219713^3 = 2197 ✓.

Suc­ces­sive dif­fer­ences

Here is one more pat­tern worth notic­ing. The dif­fer­ences between con­sec­u­tive squares are the odd num­bers 3,5,7,…3, 5, 7, \ldots, and the dif­fer­ences of those are all 22. For cubes, the first dif­fer­ences are 7,19,37,61,…7, 19, 37, 61, \ldots, the sec­ond are 12,18,24,…12, 18, 24, \ldots, and the third are all 66. So a square set­tles down after two lev­els and a cube after three.

A pinch of his­tory

Peo­ple have needed these num­bers for a very long time. Baby­lon­ian clay tablets from around 1700 BCE carry tables of squares and cubes, used for sur­vey­ing and build­ing. In San­skrit, varga meant both the square shape and the square power, and ghana meant the solid cube and the third power; Āryab­haṭa in 499 CE spells out the link clearly. Our word root comes from mūla, mean­ing the root of a plant, or ori­gin. So varga-mūla is the square root and ghana-mūla the cube root, a usage that trav­elled into Ara­bic as jidhr and into Latin as radix.

Prac­tice

  1. Find by prime fac­tori­sa­tion: 2304\sqrt{2304}, 4356\sqrt{4356}.
  2. Is 13501350 a per­fect square? If not, find the small­est num­ber to mul­ti­ply it by to make one, and the result­ing root.
  3. Find the small­est square divis­i­ble by 88, 1212 and 2020.
  4. Find 3481\sqrt{3481} by brack­et­ing and last dig­its.
  5. Between which two con­sec­u­tive whole num­bers does 450\sqrt{450} lie, and which is it nearer?
  6. A square field has area 850850 m². What is the largest square with whole-num­ber side that fits inside?
  7. Find 92613\sqrt[3]{9261} and 156253\sqrt[3]{15625} by fac­tori­sa­tion.
  8. By what small­est num­ber must 20002000 be mul­ti­plied to give a per­fect cube?
  9. Guess from the dig­its: 68593\sqrt[3]{6859}, 196833\sqrt[3]{19683}, 297913\sqrt[3]{29791}.
  10. With­out adding, state the value of 73+75+77+79+81+83+85+87+8973 + 75 + 77 + 79 + 81 + 83 + 85 + 87 + 89.
  11. True or false, with a rea­son: (a) a cube end­ing in 88 has a root end­ing in 22; (b) the cube of a two-digit num­ber can have three dig­its; (c) 41044104 is a taxi­cab num­ber.
  12. Which is largest: 503−49350^3 - 49^3, 502−49250^2 - 49^2, 303−29330^3 - 29^3?

Answers

Show answers
  1. 2304=28×32=4822304 = 2^8 \times 3^2 = 48^2: 4848. 4356=22×32×112=6624356 = 2^2 \times 3^2 \times 11^2 = 66^2: 6666.
  2. 1350=2×33×521350 = 2 \times 3^3 \times 5^2: no. Mul­ti­ply by 2×3=62 \times 3 = 6: 8100=9028100 = 90^2.
  3. LCM 120=23×3×5120 = 2^3 \times 3 \times 5; mul­ti­ply by 3030: 36003600.
  4. 502=2500<3481<3600=60250^2 = 2500 < 3481 < 3600 = 60^2; last digit 11 means 5151 or 5959; 552=3025<348155^2 = 3025 < 3481, so 5959. Check 592=348159^2 = 3481 ✓.
  5. 212=441<450<484=22221^2 = 441 < 450 < 484 = 22^2; nearer 2121.
  6. 292=841≤850<90029^2 = 841 \leq 850 < 900: side 2929 m.
  7. 9261=33×73=2139261 = 3^3 \times 7^3 = 21^3: 2121. 15625=56=25315625 = 5^6 = 25^3: 2525.
  8. 2000=24×532000 = 2^4 \times 5^3: we need two more 22s, so mul­ti­ply by 44 to get 8000=2038000 = 20^3.
  9. 1919 (ends in 99, between 10310^3 and 20320^3); 2727 (ends in 33, between 203=800020^3 = 8000 and 303=2700030^3 = 27000); 3131 (ends in 11, just above 30330^3).
  10. These are nine con­sec­u­tive odd num­bers start­ing right after the eighth group ends at 7171, so the sum is 93=7299^3 = 729.
  11. (a) True: only 232^3 ends in 88. (b) False: the small­est is 103=100010^3 = 1000. (c) True: 23+163=93+153=41042^3 + 16^3 = 9^3 + 15^3 = 4104.
  12. 503−493=3×50×49+1=735150^3 - 49^3 = 3 \times 50 \times 49 + 1 = 7351; 502−492=9950^2 - 49^2 = 99; 303−293=3×30×29+1=261130^3 - 29^3 = 3 \times 30 \times 29 + 1 = 2611. The first.